Once a student has learned to isolate a sound in a particular position in a word, you should teach that student to match words with the same beginning/ending/middle. This activity is more rigorous because it requires the student to listen to two words, identify the sound in a particular position in each word, and determine whether they are the same.
To support your student's ability to match beginning, ending, or middle sounds, you should start by explicitly teaching the skill. Here's an example of what it would sound like to teach a student to determine whether two words have the same beginning sounds (the same general format can be used for ending and middle sounds):
Show the student two objects and ask whether or not the objects have the same beginning sound. "I'm going to show you two objects. I want you to tell me if they have the same beginning sound or different beginning sounds?" [Put two objects on the table.] "This is _________. This is __________. Do they have the same beginning sound or different beginning sounds? Why?"
Same or Different in Action
Watch this clip to see this intervention in action. Implementation note: During reading intervention, it is recommended that the teacher prompt the student to repeat the original words before completing the task.
Show the student one picture and have the student repeat the name of the object. Tell the student to find a picture in the set of cards that has the same beginning sound as the object. "This is a tomato. What is it?" "Tomato." "Which picture begins with the same sound as tomato?"
Match the Sound in Action
Watch this clip to see this intervention in action. Implementation note: During reading intervention, it is recommended that the teacher prompt the student to repeat the original words before completing the task.
Preston, J., & Edwards, M. L. (2010;2009;). Phonological awareness and types of sound errors in preschoolers with speech sound disorders. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 53(1), 44-60. https://www-proquest-com.library.relay.edu/docview/507892023?pq-origsite=summon
After a student has learned how to isolate and match sounds in a particular position in a word, you can teach that student to generate words with the same beginning/ending/middle sound. This is a more advanced skill because it requires that the student isolate the sound and then retrieve a word with a sound in the same position from their long-term memory.
Explicit Instruction
Again, to support your student's ability to generate words with a particular beginning sound, you will want to explicitly teach this skill. Here is an example of what it would sound like to teach a student to generate beginning/ending/middle sounds in words. The example below focuses on beginning sounds, but you could apply the same procedure to teach students how to generate middle and ending sounds.
Activity C: Word Generation
Say a sound and have the student repeat it. Tell the student to tell you as many words as they can that start with that sound. Set the timer for one minute. "Say /m/. I'm going to set the timer for one minute. I want you to tell me as many sounds that you can think of that start with the sound /m/."
Word Generation in Action
Watch this clip to see this intervention in action. Implementation note: During reading intervention, it is recommended that the teacher prompt the student to repeat the original words before completing the task.
When you are planning your lessons, you should anticipate that your student will make errors throughout the activity. Here is a series of prompts that you can use to respond to errors. Keep in mind that all students are different, and some students might respond better to different types of feedback than others.
Think about the following scenario, which takes place after a teacher has explicitly taught a lesson about how to isolate beginning sounds:
Teacher: "What's the beginning sound in the word cat?"
Student: "c"
Teacher: "Is it the same beginning sound as "car" or "tap"?
Student: "Is it the same beginning sound as tap."
In such a case, what might you do?
Feedback During the Lesson
Level of Support | Description of Scaffold | Script |
---|---|---|
Smallest scaffold | Try Again! You are seeking to discover if the student accidentally mixed up the beginning and ending sounds, or if the student is not hearing the beginning sound. The type of feedback you will give the student depends on the type of error the student is making. Allow multiple opportunities to practice. | "That's the ending sound. Try again." |
Medium scaffold | Provide resources. Allows the student to use resources or prompts to figure out the answer (including helpful supports such as examples or strategies that allow students to focus on the sounds).
|
"I'm going to say the word cat slowly. Ready? cccaaaaaattttt. What was the beginning sound you heard?" "C." "Now, does it sound like car or tap?" |
Highest scaffold | Model, Lead, Test, Retest. Model for the student using this gradual release correction procedure adopted from Carnine, D.W., Silbert, J., Kame'enui, E. J. & Tarver, S. G. (2004). Direct instruction reading (4th Ed). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson. | 1. Teacher says the correct answer. "/k/." 2. Teacher models: "My turn. What is the beginning sound in cat?" (Signal.) "/k/.""Cat." "Car." 3. Teacher leads: "Let's do it together. What is the beginning sound in cat?" (Signal.) "/k/. Cat. Car."(Teacher responds with the students.) 4. Teacher tests: "Your turn. What is the beginning sound in cat?" (Signal.) "/k/. Cat. Car." |
If your student struggles to meet your objective, there are various techniques that you might try to adjust the activity to your student's needs.
Activity | Description of Strategy | Script |
---|---|---|
Matching or Generating Sounds | Picture It (and Say It). Show student example pictures of words with similar and different beginning/middle/ending sounds (with or without saying the words) so that they can use these cards as a cue. | "Here are three cards (show students a tomato, a tiger, a cup, and a telephone). I'll say these words: Tomato, Tiger, Cup, Telephone. As you look at each picture, say the word, and see which cards have the same beginning sound." |